# Bears, Vehicles, and Insurance. Three
Convicted in Bizarre "Bear Costume" Insurance Fraud Scheme Targeting Luxury Vehicles A bizarre insurance fraud case in California recently made headlines when three individuals were convicted for faking bear attacks on luxury vehicles. The scheme, uncovered in 2024, involved suspects claiming that a wild bear damaged their Rolls-Royce Ghost and Mercedes vehicles in the Lake Arrowhead area. Surveillance footage, reviewed by wildlife biologists, revealed the "bear" was actually a person in a costume. The California Department of Insurance investigators exposed the scam, resulting in convictions, probation sentences, and restitution orders totaling over $100,000. A fourth suspect remains pending trial. While this case was fraudulent, real encounters between bears and vehicles are far from fiction—especially for hunters and outdoor enthusiasts who frequent bear country. ## The Scheme Unfolds In January 2024, suspects Alfiya Zuckerman, 39, Ruben Tamrazian, 26, Vahe Muradkhanyan, 32, and Ararat Chirkinian, 39, filed insurance claims alleging that a wild bear had broken into their vehicles and caused extensive interior damage in Lake Arrowhead, a community in California's San Bernardino Mountains. The primary claim involved a 2010 Rolls-Royce Ghost. To support their story, the group submitted video footage showing what appeared to be a bear inside the vehicle. However, upon closer examination, California Department of Insurance detectives noticed inconsistencies in the footage. Investigators enlisted a biologist from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to analyze the videos. The expert concluded that the "bear" was "clearly a human in a bear suit." Further investigation revealed two additional fraudulent claims filed with separate insurance companies for the same date and location. These involved a 2015 Mercedes G63 AMG and a 2022 Mercedes E350, both allegedly damaged by the same "bear." During a search warrant execution at one suspect's residence, detectives recovered the actual bear costume used in the staged attacks. ## How Often Do Bears Break Into Cars in the U.S.? Bear-vehicle incidents are more common than many realize. In Colorado alone, wildlife officials documented 484 vehicle break-ins by black bears between 2019 and 2020. These incidents typically occur when bears detect food, coolants, or even air fresheners inside parked cars. Unlocked doors and open windows make vehicles easy targets. Recent data shows bear-human conflicts are rising. Colorado Parks and Wildlife reported a record 5,300 bear sightings and conflict reports in 2025—the highest in six years. Similar trends appear across the country, from New Hampshire to California, where bears have been caught on security cameras breaking into cars, sometimes spending hours trapped inside after entering through open windows. For hunters storing gear, food, or scented items in vehicles at trailheads or campsites, these statistics underscore a simple rule: never leave attractants in your car, and always lock doors—even in remote areas. ## Wildlife Damage and Insurance Claims: The Real Numbers When wild animals damage vehicles, insurance claims add up quickly. According to State Farm, U.S. drivers filed approximately 1.7 million auto insurance claims related to animal collisions between July 2024 and June 2025. While deer account for the majority of these incidents, comprehensive coverage also applies to damage caused by bears, rodents, birds, and other wildlife. Nationwide, over one million vehicle-wildlife collisions occur annually, resulting in more than $8 billion in property damage and thousands of human injuries. Claim frequency peaks each November, coinciding with deer mating season and increased animal movement at dawn and dusk. Importantly, damage from animals breaking into or damaging a parked vehicle falls under *comprehensive* insurance coverage—not collision coverage. However, comprehensive policies typically do not cover personal belongings stolen or damaged during a break-in, only vehicle repairs. ## Practical Tips for Hunters 1. **Secure Your Vehicle**: Always lock doors and close windows when parking in bear country. Store food, gear, and scented items in bear-proof containers or inside your residence—not in the car overnight. 2. **Review Your Policy**: Confirm your auto insurance includes comprehensive coverage. Understand deductibles and claim procedures before heading into the field. 3. **Document Incidents**: If wildlife damages your vehicle, photograph the scene and file a police report. This documentation supports insurance claims and helps wildlife agencies track conflict patterns. 4. **Stay Alert in Peak Seasons**: Animal activity increases in autumn. Drive cautiously during dawn and dusk, especially in rural or forested areas. The California bear-costume fraud case reminds us that while some try to exploit wildlife encounters for profit, real human-bear conflicts carry genuine risks—and costs. For hunters who value both the outdoors and responsible stewardship, staying informed about wildlife behavior and insurance preparedness helps protect both property and the animals we share the landscape with.